‘It’s cheaper, democratic and what users want’: Why councils need to think about accessibility

Written by Gill Hitchcock on 6 October 2016 in Features
Features

RNIB inclusion guru Steve Tyler tells Gill Hitchcock that it makes sense for councils to build accessibility into their digital services. 

Blind or partially sighted people can have trouble using councils' websites on the move - Photo credit: Flickr, Georgie Pauwels

The Royal National Institute of Blind People has a challenge for local authorities: to submit their apps and digital services for accessibility accreditation by the charity. And, if their services or apps aren’t accessible, the RNIB will help them reach that goal.

Some businesses already have the charity’s accessibility quality assurance mark for their digital products. For instance, this summer, NatWest’s banking app became the first in the banking sector to be ‘RNIB Approved’.

NatWest used existing iPhone and Android technology, but broke new ground by making 160 adjustments – including allowing text on to be read out loud to the user – to support its 10,000 customers who have some form of visual impairment.

Another private sector success story is the British Gas app, which allows blind and partially-sighted householders to control their heating and hot water systems using their Android smartphone by using the phone’s voice control features.

Call to arms

But the public sector is yet to follow suit. When asked if any council apps are in line for RNIB accreditation, Steve Tyler, head of solutions and planning at the charity, offers a diplomatic response: “Not at the moment.”

Tyler says digital technologies create huge opportunities for councils to serve all citizens, but there is “massive variability” in accessibility across local authority websites.

About 25% of sites reviewed by the RNIB are reasonably accessible, while the rest vary from “kind of okay to really difficult”, he says. “I have one of the most powerful screen reading technologies on the planet – JAWS – and it can’t deal with some of them.”


Related content

Digital inclusion chief calls on government to improve accessibility laws
Mobile accessibility lags behind desktop, says Socitm survey of council websites
​GDS cuts eg, ie and etc from style guide


Blind and partially-sighted people face major obstacles downloading council forms and reports, Tyler says. They are often in a PDF format that hasn’t been made accessible, or include tables that are poorly set out so a screen reader can’t identify what the data represent.

“One example is if you want to get your bins emptied on a particular day, or you want some rubbish collected,” he says.

“It’s all very well being able to get to the right place on the website, but then you’ve got a form or a process to tangle with, which is very likely nothing to do with the website design itself. It’s been laid out by somebody else.”

Images are another challenge for blind people, unless they are labelled so that a screen reader can identify what they represent. “The simple expedient of just adding a label is a game changer. It’s not difficult, but you’ve got to know to do that,” says Tyler.

Councils need to go through the “extra step of cascading information right through their systems, so whoever is creating [documents and pages] from the outset knows what good practice is”, he says.

But, despite the problems, accessibility is becoming mainstream. Tyler says people generally expect to be able to communicate using their devices in different ways, and that this technology means councils can design services that are available to everyone. Well-designed online processes are cheaper, too.

On the other hand, poorly designed services that exclude disabled people will cost councils money.

“People will go onto the website, not be able to handle it and not find what they want,” he says. “You are likely to get a call with the original question or challenge, as well as ‘And by the way, I tried to get onto your website, can you help me to deal with that’. And you have just bought yourself a whole additional nightmare.”

Building awareness

Tyler says that the problem with encouraging accessibility is that people think it is difficult and expensive, but “it really, really isn’t”. It does not add much to development costs, he says, especially if you build in accessibility from the start on a new site.

The most important part to accessibility is awareness. Teams have to gather the knowledge to do it.

However, Tyler admits that spreading the message about good accessibility can be complicated when councils outsource web design. Even if the design is done in house, knowledge is often lacking.

He points out that there is an abundance of advice and support on offer. “If you’re making an Apple-based app, it’s very difficult to escape messages about accessibility. It’s just good practice.

“If you are making an Android-based app there are so many resources. There are web consortium guidelines freely available, telling you exactly what best practice is to create a website. Even if all you do is label things properly, then you’re well on your way to making it work.”

Tyler cites shopping delivery service Ocado’s app – made by the same team as the apps for Waitrose and Morrison’s – as a good example.

“We worked with them to make their app fully accessible, we accredited them, and they can use exactly the same technology in any other piece of work,” he says. “That’s the kind of message that we want to spread right through government services.”

Tyler wants councils to be “more alive” to the very different needs in society that can be handled by proper navigability or mark up on a website, or by an accessible app.

Poor accessibility affects citizens’ ability to access services, and it threatens their democratic rights, he argues. For instance if information about local elections is not readily available to disabled people, they are being directly discriminated against.

“In the end, we elect councillors to do a job. And we are all responsible for those elections, or we are in theory, and we want to hold those guys to account,” he says. “If you can’t get to that process, then accountability simply isn’t there.”

About the author

Gill Hitchcock is a health and public services journalist.

Share this page

Tags

Categories

Comments

johnar@me.com

Submitted on 18 October, 2016 - 16:14
Several phases of funding have been utilised to help with accessibility. Lancashire's Digital Development Agency funded a project that created a service for the Blind and partially sighted which delivered audio based content, news, advice, information to over 400 individuals in the Northwest (it was founded at the digital recording studios of N-Vision in Blackpool). The service developed simplified audio menus and easy to manage operation for a service called "blueIRIS". While supported by Blackpool Council initially, they never saw the value it brought and it was never adopted. The amazing thing was that the service grew a global audience while it was growing. Alas, neither Blackpool Council nor other bodies saw contributing to be of sufficient value to continue its pioneering start! If anyone is interested, the project is replicable (more so today with technologies now better suited to multi-media operation and accessibility). It had many possible routes into many different public sector services. Contact me via www.johnar.net for more information.

Add new comment

Related Articles

Analysis: HMRC tops central government digital league table
7 August 2017

Collation of performance-dashboard stats shows department is conducting almost all its transactions digitally, while other departments struggle to reach two thirds

How Birmingham City Council ditched ‘vanity projects’ and transformed its white-elephant website
20 September 2017

Council’s assistant director of customer services tells PublicTechnology how Europe’s largest local authority asked youthful citizens to help it build an online home that is fit for...

Digital chief lifts lid on how HMRC pulled off the biggest tax change in 70 years without anyone noticing
15 September 2017

Interim CDIO Mike Potter also discusses how the department is leading the way on mobile apps and blockchain, and why he wants a tax service built around life events

Whitehall digital reform being slowly undone by ‘departmental barons’, warns Francis Maude
14 September 2017

But civil service head Jeremy Heywood hits back and claims government departments are ‘sharply improving digital capacity’

Related Sponsored Articles

Why field service management is vital for public sector organisations
18 September 2017

Kirona explains what field service is and why public sector organisations need to implement an effective field service management solution  

BT and See.Sense light the way for safe cycling in Manchester with Internet of Things project
16 August 2017

BT will launch a new project with See.Sense, an innovative cycling company from Northern Ireland, to provide cyclists with sensor-enabled bike lights