Fears Government Digital Service being “dismembered” as it prepares to lose data policy to DCMS

Written by PublicTechnology.net staff on 6 February 2018 in News

Warning of “Whitehall asset-stripping” as policy-focused DCMS looks set to gain chunk of GDS remit

Culture secretary Matt Hancock heads the department that is reportedly gaining control of data policy for government. Credit: PA

The Government Digital Service will hand over control of data policy and governance to the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport later this year, it has been reported – sparking fears that the central Cabinet Office team is having its wings significantly clipped.

GDS was set up by the coalition government to take a lead on digital policy right across government, imposing central spend controls on tech projects and introducing tough new standards for government websites and digital services.

But its future has been the subject of repeated speculation in recent years, with frequent leadership changes and ministerial churn in the Cabinet Office raising questions over whether departmental priorities were reasserting themselves and undermining the centralising vision of GDS.

Related Content

Citing multiple sources, the website Diginomica has now reported that GDS is set to lose responsibility for data policy and governance from April 1, with the remit given to the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS). DCMS, which last year added the word ‘Digital’ to its title, is led by former Cabinet Office minister Matt Hancock, who briefly held responsibility for GDS as Cabinet Office minister from 2015 to 2016.

In a statement, the Cabinet Office neither confirmed nor denied the report, saying only: “The Cabinet Office and the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport have been looking at how to bring together and further strengthen their work on the use and management of data across government. An announcement will follow in due course.”

DCMS already has responsibility for data protection policy across the wider economy, but GDS leads cross-government efforts to ensure that departments themselves use and manage data properly, including by setting up authoritative canonical registers to avoid needless duplication across departments.

Responding to the latest report in a piece for PublicTechnology’s sister publication Civil Service World, former senior Cabinet Office digital staffer Andrew Greenway expressed fear that handing responsibility for data over “to a small, policy-led department like DCMS” appeared part of the “dismembering” of GDS.

“Replacing a weakened centre with diffuse departmental effort is a mistake, because it strips a critical function out of government,” he said. 

“The point of GDS was to have a single team that could act as the voice of users for government as a whole. To do that well, it needed a mandate covering data as well as design, operations and technology. It also had to have a clear mission. 

"Increasingly, it has neither of these. The departmental shape of government gives no incentive for any non-central department to step in. It is a great shame that the two most well-placed advocates for an effective centre — the Treasury and [cabinet secretary] Sir Jeremy Heywood — have proved unable or unwilling to stop the rot.”

Greenway accused ministers of “rearranging the deckchairs” in government digital, and said senior officials focused on “Whitehall asset-stripping” now appeared keen to carve up the service.

“The talent that remains is a valuable prize. GDS’ policy reach and brand is attractive to empire builders too. There are several Whitehall islands who could make credible arguments for snatching away parts of the territory.”

Greenway’s views on the future of GDS chime with those expressed by Martha Lane-Fox – the tech entrepreneur whose 2011 report for government was instrumental in the setting up of GDS – in a speech last year.

“Departmental silos are creeping back, replicating cost and inefficiency and, most importantly, letting down citizens,” she said.

“GDS is celebrated and copied around the world. Last year we were ranked top for digital government by the UN. How ironic if we fail to recognise and nurture this great asset.”

Share this page




Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.

Related Articles

Report calls for ‘more power’ in Whitehall to be centralised
26 January 2021

UK’s top two civil servants should be handed more responsibility as part of drive to make Cabinet Office more effective, says IfG

Government shakes up digital leadership
12 January 2021

Home Office tech chief Davinson appointed leader of newly created Central Digital and Data Office while Read arrives from MoJ to head up GDS

Related Sponsored Articles

Email security incidents happen every 12 hours – it’s time to close the gap in Microsoft 365
21 January 2021

The remote-first world has seen email being relied on more than ever as a core communication mechanism - but with 93% of IT leaders acknowledging a risk to sensitive data, what steps should be...

Remote working opened the doors to cyberattack and data breach risks – we can close them
8 December 2020

In 2020 public sector organisations have been tested to a degree never experienced before. According to CrowdStrike, increasing cybersecurity attacks are an additional complication they must...