Rights groups question whether plans for NHS data store are ‘appropriate, lawful and just’

Written by Liam Kirkaldy on 22 May 2020 in News
News

Signatories including Liberty and Open Knowledge Foundation call for greater transparency

Credit: Michael Mandiberg/CC BY-SA 2.0 

A group of digital rights organisations have expressed concern over plans for a new NHS Covid-19 data store, warning health and social secretary Matt Hancock that “transparency has been lacking”.

The government first announced plans for the data store in March, in an attempt to track the spread of Covid-19 and how it will impact on the NHS and social care services.

But in an open letter, 27 organisations and advocates said that the plans, based on Microsoft, Google, Palantir, Faculty and Amazon assisting in the development of the data store, would give private partners control over sensitive data.


Related content

 


The signatories, which include Liberty, the Open Knowledge Foundation and Big Brother Watch, warned the “opacity in which these agreements are made does not help [in] building this trust”.

The letter said: “Emergencies require rapid responses, but these responses should also be appropriate, lawful and just. It’s unlikely that the NHS’s current plan to build a large-scale Covid-19 data store meets those principles.  We understand the need for better health information, but maintain that the public should be consulted throughout the development of the datastore and be able to obtain adequate information about the data-sharing agreements in place. “

It added: “We urge the NHS to provide answers to all of the questions below and to not proceed with the development of the data store until the public has had a chance to have their say.”

 

About the author

Liam Kirkaldy is online editor at PublicTechnology sister publication Holyrood, where this story first appeared. He tweets as @HolyroodLiam.

Tags

Share this page

Tags

Categories

CONTRIBUTIONS FROM READERS

Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.

Related Articles

Justice secretary scolded for leaking stats on transgender prisoners to press
1 December 2021

UKSA chair says giving data to journalists ahead of official release ‘risks misinforming the public’

Government hopes transparency standard can build trust in departments’ use of algorithms
30 November 2021

New guidelines created by Central Digital and Data Office

Home Office to spearhead anti-encryption public comms campaign
17 January 2022

Report claims efforts led by advertising firm will aim to stoke concern among parents and could feature public stunts designed to alarm passers-by 

Standards watchdog flags up accountability concerns over ministers’ use of WhatsApp
13 January 2022

Lord Evans tells MPs that personal messaging platforms should only be used by ministers if doing so can be properly regulated