Statistics watchdog warns PM again over inaccurate claim on employment increase

Written by Tevye Markson on 18 May 2022 in News
News

In his ninth such proclamation in the last six months, Boris Johnson cited a rise of 500,000 since 2020 – rather than a decline of 588,000

Credit: EU Estonian Presidency/CC BY 2.0

The UK Statistics Authority has warned Boris Johnson once again over his use of statistics after he made a false claim about employment levels in parliament for the ninth time. 

The prime minister said at Prime Minister’s Questions on 27 April that there were 500,000 more people in paid employment than before the Covid-19 pandemic.

In fact, there were 588,000 fewer people in employment in the UK compared to two years ago, according to the latest Office for National Statistics figures.

Johnson made the comments in the House of Commons before the ONS published updated employment stats today showing the unemployment rate had fallen slightly between January and March to hit a nearly 50-year low. However, total employment nevertheless remains lower than pre-pandemic levels.

The latest ONS data shows that there were 32.569 million people in employment across the UK in January to March this year, compared to 33.073 million in December 2019 to February 2020.

While there are now more people on payrolls than before the pandemic, this increase is more than offset by the reduction in the number of people who are self-employed.

Sian Jones, interim chair of UKSA, said: “The prime minister should be clearer in his claims around employment now compared to before the pandemic began."

The PM has previously made eight similar incorrect claims on employment figures at PMQs since November, according to fact checking charity Full Fact.

Jones addressed Johnson’s latest comments in a letter to Liberal Democrat MP Christine Jardine, who had written to the authority to ask what can be done to prevent the PM from repeating the claim again in future.

“The UK Statistics Authority seeks to protect the role of statistics in public debate; we want to see statistics used and interpreted appropriately,” Jones said.

“We will continue to emphasise the importance of accuracy and clarity with Number 10, and work with producers to present statistics in ways which minimise the risk of misuse,” she added.

UKSA has already warned Johnson over his use of statistics several times this year, including over the same false claim.

Former UKSA chair Sir David Norgrove wrote to Johnson on 24 February, reproaching him for his “selective” use of unemployment statistics at PMQs three weeks earlier.

Norgrove also criticised the PM in January for stating that crime had gone down by 14% when it had actually risen by 14%. Johnson omitted fraud and computer use from the figures to get the “misleading” figure.

Ed Humpherson, director general for regulation at the Office for Statistics Regulation, has also previously raised concerns about Johnson’s “disappointing” use of statistics, writing to Laura Gilbert, No.10’s director of data science, on 1 February.

And Jones said her office has also been in touch with the No.10 briefing team on “a number of occasions” over the false statements.

 

About the author

Tevye Markson is a reporter at PublicTechnology sister publication Civil Service World, where a version of this story first appeared. He tweets as @TevyeMarkson.

Share this page

Tags

Categories

CONTRIBUTIONS FROM READERS

Please login to post a comment or register for a free account.

Related Articles

10 Downing St offers over £100k for data science whizz
23 June 2022

Prime minister’s in-house data science unit seeks senior manager to deliver ‘high-impact’ initiatives 

Parliament to delete data on MPs’ attendance after ministers decry FOI release
22 June 2022

Senior parliamentarians are understood to have complained about the storage and release of information collected from use of security passes

NHS app to widen users’ access to health records
13 June 2022

Strategy makes commitment to allow patients to view a greater range of information

One in three departments expect to miss target for publishing FY22 annual report
4 May 2022

Evidence from Treasury permanent secretary reveals that eight Whitehall departments believe they will not achieve 30 June publication target